A fluttering of canaries in the news media coal mine

Are we being prepared for an end to TVNZ’s ‘flagship’ news hour at 6 pm?

Yesterday the state-owned broadcaster announced it was making changes to its news teams “to be less tied to a broadcasting schedule”. In other words, it is moving its focus toward its digital platforms.

A spokesperson stated that TVNZ was “not looking to reduce the size of our newsroom as part of this”. However, it is unlikely that the ‘assurance’ fully assuaged the anxiety caused by the way staff were invited to the meeting at which the plan was unveiled: They were “welcome to bring a support person”. Bitter experience has taught journalists not to count their chickens until after plans have been fully implemented.

Inevitably, however, a focus on digital delivery will take resources away from broadcast bulletins. Three hours of Business/Breakfast and an hour of primetime television from 6pm – ninety minutes if you include Seven Sharp – takes a lot of filling. It is only a matter of time before changes are announced to both morning and evening offerings.

The breakfast mixture could change without having too much impact on the life of the average New Zealander but changes to the primetime offering is another matter entirely.

NZ on Air’s Where are the Audiences Report 2026 shows that about 80 per cent of those above the age of 50 remain connected to broadcast television. There is also clear evidence that the 60+ audience is wedded to the nightly news bulletin. For many it is their primary source of news and information and a habit that has been with them for decades. Equally significant is the fact that this segment of their audience is the least connected with digital platforms — if they use them at all.

A cutback from an hour (or ninety minutes) to a 30-minute 6pm bulletin will materially reduce that age group’s access to news.

The smart young things in marketing departments think the old don’t count but the age group wedded to the 6 pm news probably has greater purchasing power than the 20-somethings who dip in and out of digital media without even registering the advertising on it.

TVNZ has yet to reveal any of the detail of its digital focus. Admittedly, it had to do something: Its website is almost static compared to some competing news sites. However, after the cuts it has already made to its workforce, it does not have the resources to make that shift without adversely impacting other areas of its operations.

Of course, cuts to its news broadcasts will be only the beginning. At some point TVNZ will pull the plug on linear broadcasting altogether. For those of an age where sitting down for an evening of television remains the norm, it will be a toss up which comes first – the switch off or death. Either way, they will be terminally deprived.

The end of broadcast services will be the final act in the breakdown of a commercial model that has sustained television in this country since the 1960s. It remains to be seen whether TVNZ can find sufficient income from digital to take it beyond this decade. It is currently looking at a loss of almost $49 million over the next two years.

In spite of that, it has undertaken to pay dividends to the government ($3.8 million this year) and, apart from the sop of allowing advertising on Sundays, the current government has done little to assist TVNZ — or any other news media for that matter.

Whichever coalition of parties forms the next government, it will be faced with existential threats to our news media across the board. We WILL see the growth of significant news deserts unless there are collective efforts to prevent them developing

Its first challenge will be the predicament facing Radio New Zealand.

While RNZ’s financial dilemma is entirely of its own making, it will be a foolish government that plays Pontius Pilate and leaves it to its fate.

Caretaker Prime Minister Christopher Luxon intimated to Mike Hosking on NewstalkZB yesterday that he would be doing exactly that. One could almost hear the splash of water as he ritualistically washed his hands of the problem. There was no repeat, however, of Pilate’s verdict when Christ was brought before him that he could find no fault. Quite clearly Mr Luxon was dropping the whole mess right in RNZ’s lap.

“We’re not bailing them out of anything like that. That’s their problem to deal with. And they should. As they should. We shouldn’t have to bail them out, you know, their mistake there.”

It’s hardly a quotation worthy of the King James version of the Bible, but we get his drift.

However, Mr Luxon may lack the intuition of the Roman Governor of Judea. Doing nothing may in the long run be the wrong move.

The state broadcaster is undoubtedly author of its own misfortune but, as with any agency of the state, its ability to carry out its civic role is ultimately determined by the support (or otherwise) it receives from the government of the day. That civic role has been determined by Parliament and is set out in the charter under which RNZ operates. If bad financial management and oversight prevents the broadcaster from meeting its charter obligations, its owner must stump up.

In this case, it would amount to the government instructing Treasury to forego a portion of the $51 million from the sale of RNZ land in Henderson. While RNZ has no entitlement to that money – ultimately the land is owned by the Crown – it provides the Government with the means to bring the broadcaster’s books back into balance – even if it has the distinct taste of dead rat.

Successive New Zealand governments are familiar with the taste. Poor decision-making and inadequate oversight are not he sole province of Radio New Zealand. Government departments are regularly guilty of the same thing. Witness MBIE’s writing off of $50.7 million on a botched and abandoned Immigration New Zealand biometrics project.

Both the caretaker government and whatever replaces it have a responsibility to ensure RNZ does not fail. Its board and new chief executive may lack the resources – financial and human – to ensure the broadcaster is fit to continue to deliver on its charter obligations. Losing a sixth of its workforce and projecting more financial losses does not guarantee it can continue to do so.

Ongoing losses suggest the 60-odd staff who are about to lose their jobs at RNZ will not be the last. The point is fast approaching where the broadcaster will be meeting its charter obligations more in name than in spirit. Incoming chief executive Jason Winstanley will doubtless have some innovative changes in mind, but he is not a miracle worker. He is market savvy but if Mr Luxon and his neoliberal-leaning colleagues think the market will solve RNZ’s problems, they are deluding themselves. RNZ is required by law to provide non-commercial services and is therefore dependent on the Crown for its funding. Telling RNZ to run commercials is not the answer. There is already too little money to go around the media.

RNZ has to put its house in order and ensure it has the management and governance structures in place to ensure the present mess is not repeated. Operationally, however, it could well need the help Mr Luxon is currently denying it. There may be hope, however, in the caretaker prime minister’s known ability to change his mind.

I agree with a comprehensive editorial published yesterday in The Post. It rightly held RNZ to account for its failings (and its ability to sail on with state funding while its commercial counterparts coped with ever-tightening budgets) but recognised it as “an essential service”. The editorial acknowledged the need for cuts to rectify RNZ’s appalling financial state but rightly stated that “the coming cuts should be made with caution and with care, so that RNZ can keep telling the stories other media can’t”.

It is plain to see that RNZ’s ability to meet its charter obligations are challenged by the ‘remedy’ for its current problems. However, the ability of private sector media and TVNZ to meet their own social contracts with the New Zealand public is equally in jeopardy.

That phrase “other media can’t” will be heard increasing over the term of the next government. The ability of our commercially funded media to maintain the levels of journalism that the country requires to function as a socially cohesive democracy is being continually threatened. The time is well passed where cuts can be made without materially affecting the ability to carry out their fundamental news-gathering operations.

If we are to have news media that are fit for purpose, there must be systemic and structural changes. The market alone cannot do that. If it could, the changes would have happened long ago.

Leave a Reply

Turn on JavaScript to leave a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.