A fluttering of canaries in the news media coal mine

Are we being prepared for an end to TVNZ’s ‘flagship’ news hour at 6 pm?

Yesterday the state-owned broadcaster announced it was making changes to its news teams “to be less tied to a broadcasting schedule”. In other words, it is moving its focus toward its digital platforms.

A spokesperson stated that TVNZ was “not looking to reduce the size of our newsroom as part of this”. However, it is unlikely that the ‘assurance’ fully assuaged the anxiety caused by the way staff were invited to the meeting at which the plan was unveiled: They were “welcome to bring a support person”. Bitter experience has taught journalists not to count their chickens until after plans have been fully implemented.

Inevitably, however, a focus on digital delivery will take resources away from broadcast bulletins. Three hours of Business/Breakfast and an hour of primetime television from 6pm – ninety minutes if you include Seven Sharp – takes a lot of filling. It is only a matter of time before changes are announced to both morning and evening offerings.

The breakfast mixture could change without having too much impact on the life of the average New Zealander but changes to the primetime offering is another matter entirely.

NZ on Air’s Where are the Audiences Report 2026 shows that about 80 per cent of those above the age of 50 remain connected to broadcast television. There is also clear evidence that the 60+ audience is wedded to the nightly news bulletin. For many it is their primary source of news and information and a habit that has been with them for decades. Equally significant is the fact that this segment of their audience is the least connected with digital platforms — if they use them at all.

A cutback from an hour (or ninety minutes) to a 30-minute 6pm bulletin will materially reduce that age group’s access to news.

The smart young things in marketing departments think the old don’t count but the age group wedded to the 6 pm news probably has greater purchasing power than the 20-somethings who dip in and out of digital media without even registering the advertising on it.

TVNZ has yet to reveal any of the detail of its digital focus. Admittedly, it had to do something: Its website is almost static compared to some competing news sites. However, after the cuts it has already made to its workforce, it does not have the resources to make that shift without adversely impacting other areas of its operations.

Of course, cuts to its news broadcasts will be only the beginning. At some point TVNZ will pull the plug on linear broadcasting altogether. For those of an age where sitting down for an evening of television remains the norm, it will be a toss up which comes first – the switch off or death. Either way, they will be terminally deprived. Continue reading “A fluttering of canaries in the news media coal mine” →

We wanted the facts and got endless entertainment

A subliminal utterance kept playing in my head as I watched hours of prediction and speculation on election night. It was the voice of Sergeant Joe Friday.

Most of you would be too young to know Sergeant Friday. Dragnet, the series in which he featured, was broadcast on New Zealand radio in the 1950s. His signature phrase was “All we want are the facts, Ma’am”.

And that was all I wanted after the polling booths closed at 7 pm on Saturday. All I wanted were the results.

Instead, every news outlet gave me proof that British naval historian C. Northcote Parkinson was right: Work does expand to fill the time available for its completion. Each outlet had lots of time to fill as the vote count continued throughout the evening.

I was prepared for prediction and speculation. That is the nature of emerging political fortunes, and those offering it do so in the expectation that things will become clearer as the night progressed. It’s an unfortunate fact that clarity and New Zealand’s emerging brand of Mixed Member Proportional Representation take longer to come together than First Past the Post.

There was also a certain inevitability about the appearance of BWC graphics. BWC? It stands for Because We Can and denotes the use of elaborate studio graphic overlays that can place thoroughly urbanised presenters in territory that Indiana Jones would struggle to reach.  On election night it had TVNZ’s intrepid Jason Walls theatrically scaling the heights of massive columns and trekking along fast-moving bar graphs. TV3/Stuff may have had less grunt in the electronics department but it, too, managed to paint the floor with graphics that contained less information than the straightforward charts it also displayed.

And, although their ephemeral nature makes the information harder to assimilate, the tickertape results along the bottom of the screen were there as expected. And, as anticipated, they went in one eye and out the other.

All this paled, however, alongside the retreat into entertainment in which both TVOne and TV3/Stuff freely engaged. Such actions on both networks detracted from the serious business of the evening. TVOne wanted your election party photos, while 3/Stuff played bingo with its audience. Live crosses to election parties in people’s homes? Spare me! Continue reading “We wanted the facts and got endless entertainment” →

What makes this imprisoned paedophile so different?

I want to see the Criminal Procedure Act changed.  I want an addition to Section 200 on suppression of names, and I’ve made it easy for the incoming government by writing the draft clause.

 In proceedings related to the sexual abuse and exploitation of minors and the possession of Child Sexual Abuse Material, the name of any person sentenced to a term of imprisonment may be permanently suppressed only when the interests of the juvenile victims of the offence would be compromised by publication.

You may be able to guess what has prompted the call. Frankly, I was outraged when I saw the front page of the New Zealand Herald last Friday and the headline ‘Wealthy offender to keep name secret’.

The offender in question had been jailed for two years and five months after being found with more than 11,000 ‘objectionable publications’ depicting sexual exploitation of children ranging from toddlers to prepubescent girls. Some images were sadistic and one depicted bestiality. He was granted permanent name suppression, as were the name of his family and their high-profile company, and given a discount for making $50,000 charitable donation days before his sentencing date.

The Crown appealed the permanent suppression but last week it lost that appeal. Justice Michael Arthur’s decision said the experience of being arrested and the fear of going to prison was “stressful” for the man and had precipitated a decline in his mental health. Information put before the court showed the man had a long history of mental health difficulties, pre-dating the discovery of his crimes. Reports expressed serious concerns for the man’s mental state should he be publicly identified, and the guilt he would carry about his offending negatively affecting his family and their business. The decision supported the sentencing judge’s decision in suppressing the company’s name after ruling that publication could cause the firm undue hardship and reputational damage “because it might be unfairly linked with the offending”.

I cannot disagree more profoundly. It is yet another example of wealth proving a factor in the way the guilty are treated by the courts.

I am going to set out a number of cases where men have been sentenced to imprisonment on charges relating to child pornography and, in each case, the defendant was named. Then I will invite you to answer a question. Continue reading “What makes this imprisoned paedophile so different?” →

Beware a society that lacks clear boundaries

I am about to utter an unpopular – and to some old-fashioned – word: Boundaries. There, I’ve said it, and now you must puzzle over what it means.

Let me give you a small clue. I am not talking about the fours and sixes Glenn Phillips scored at Hagley Oval against India on Saturday. And the Concise Oxford Dictionary provides you with limited assistance with its definition of “a line marking the limits of an area”.

The old-fashioned concept that I am discussing in this commentary refers to limits, or the rules that societies impose on behaviour and communication in order to stop their members slipping back to a life that Thomas Hobbes described as “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short”.

Every society has them. Most societies – not only Christian – generally hold at least four of the Ten Commandments as immutable: Thou shalt not murder, steal, bear false witness, or covert your neighbour’s house/wife/animals. Others move, alongside changes in the social fabric and beliefs over time. There would be a lot of dead people, for example, if adultery still saw miscreants stoned.

Each society has expectations of how its members will behave and those presumptions are not limited to what we might generally term criminality. They extend to the ways we interact with our fellow beings.

Some of these social boundaries are defined by law. In a democracy these laws are seen broadly as reflecting the limits that society wishes to see imposed on itself, although increasingly polarised politics may interfere with that notion. In autocracies such laws are used not for a common good but to confine and control populations.

Other boundaries, however, are tied to the presumption that the rights we claim come with responsibilities. The Golden Rule had been around a long time before Jesus proclaimed that we should do unto others as we would have them do unto us. Boundaries are about reciprocity: We observe them in order to also protect ourselves.

The problem with these boundaries, however, lies in how they are defined…or more to the point, not defined. Many of society’s limits are ‘understood’ as the rules we learn as children, as we enter society and interact with other members of it, and which unique circumstances create by forms of common consent. They are open to interpretation, and misinterpretation. Continue reading “Beware a society that lacks clear boundaries” →