Large cracks in newsrooms’ critical path to the future

The warning sign over the future of newsrooms is the one found on the London Underground: Mind the Gap.

A future newsrooms study jointly undertaken by the Financial Times and the World Association of News Publishers surveyed 86 countries, including New Zealand. It found four interconnected gaps that are preventing newsrooms from turning plans about their future into a new reality. Many are falling short on strategy, audience trust, capabilities, and skills.

There is no shortage of ideas, and the direction of travel seems to be well understood, but translating that into action is proving harder than many imagined. In the introduction to the report, FT Strategies director Lisa MacLeod issued a stark wake-up call: “Our newsrooms are not well prepared for a disrupted future”.

She put it bluntly, saying that while there was talk of “a grand game about audience-first journalism”, actual workflows tell a different story. Almost two-thirds of newsrooms are still based on single-channel legacy structures. These structures are throttling transformation because content is still produced for a primary platform and then only adapted for other purposes that should have equal (or higher) priority.

Throughout the report there are recurring references to the audience-first journalism that, in most cases, is more a noble aim than a reality. There are exceptions, however, and New Zealand provides one of them.

The report highlights a service-oriented journalism initiative by Stuff that encourages readers to contact the newsroom with problems they want Stuff journalists to investigate. Since it was launched last September, the service has received more than 500 submissions from people who are ‘ticked off’ about something. Solving Stuff has investigated everything from fraud to missing suitcases. The first 10 stories generated more than 420,000 pageviews.

The feature is notable for both its direct reader input and its transparency. It explains the steps a Stuff journalist takes to investigate the problem and, if the problem isn’t solved, it says so. The result is a feature which gives readers a sense of direct involvement that is enhanced by a candid approach on the part of the Stuff journalists involved – Natalie Akoorie and Tony Wall.

It is one example of how audience engagement can work but the problems facing newsrooms are wider and more deep-seated than can be solved with a single initiative. The challenges demand a newsroom-wide end-to-end cycle that is similar to the concept-to-market approach used in product development. Editorial departments are not always good at that sort of thing. Continue reading “Large cracks in newsrooms’ critical path to the future” →

Play the game to spread the news

If Albert Einstein could say “Life is just like a game”, who am I to say we shouldn’t treat the news like a game, too?

Traditionalists will say the news is no game. It is a serious matter of fact gathering, verification, and presentation that is not be treated lightly.

However, two pieces I read last week gave me pause for thought: Does gaming have a significant role to play in the future of journalism?

The first piece was an interview that Liam Dann conducted with Dame Wendy Pye for the New Zealand Herald. In it the highly successful educational book publisher said: “I’m really interested in the power of the gaming industry. [Gaming] seems to be occupying a lot of children so what my dream is to have really good educational games … not just something about a giraffe running around with the letter G on the screen or something. Imagine if we can use gaming’s magic and we can marry that with solid education.” She is working with a large Chinese company to develop her idea. If education, I thought, why not journalism?

The second piece was a research report by NZ on Air on Māori audiences. It found that rangitahi (which it characterised as 15 to 24-year-olds), like their Pakeha counterparts, are less likely to engage with television, radio or newspapers and express little interest in traditional news content.They are more likely to consume global online media than New Zealand content. They are arguably harder to reach than other sections of the wider community so present the toughest challenge. However, the same report notes that a third of Māori game online and spend an average of two hours a day doing so. Rangitahi are unsurprisingly the largest gaming group among Māori. That, I thought, could be the key to exposing them to the news. Continue reading “Play the game to spread the news” →