Matthew Hooton’s controversial appointment: A smart move?

 It takes a lot to bowl over seasoned journalists but the appointment of Matthew Hooton as editor-in-chief of The Post in Wellington skittled more than a few. Even the Stuff website described it as “a bombshell move”.

Hooton’s background is political communication and public relations. He was one of Jim Bolger’s press secretaries and a National Party strategist. He has never been a journalist, although his commentaries have been a regular feature in the New Zealand Herald and other publications.

His website describes him as “the country’s leading centre-right political commentator”. It goes on to say he “is well connected with the most senior figures in all three parties in New Zealand’s centre-right National-Act-NZ First Coalition Government and with the Opposition Labour Party.” Perhaps he is not on the Green Party or Te Pāti Māori invitation lists.

Although he has widespread consulting experience beyond politics, it is his perceived political leanings that will create the greatest controversy over his appointment at The Post.

There will be critics aplenty, who will see The Post being printed on blue paper and espousing the unchallenged views of the Right (with a very large Capital R). They will be goaded into red-faced rage when they see the title of his recently completed PhD thesis: “Groundwork and Principles of Applied Conservatism”.

I suspect that controversy has a large part to play in Sinead Boucher’s decision to appoint him editor-in-chief of Wellington’s daily newspaper, but it will not be through any desire to provide him with a powerful soapbox for political allegiances. Continue reading “Matthew Hooton’s controversial appointment: A smart move?”

NZ news media need higher productivity – from the rest of us

Even at his most philosophical, columnist Matthew Hooton is a realist. That made his economic alignment of New Zealand with the likes of Kazakhstan just a little scary.

He is entitled to be philosophical (he has a doctorate in the discipline) but last week’s column in the New Zealand Herald was brutally material: If we continue our steady-as-she-goes, borrow-and-hope, growth-will-come economic prescription of the past 17 years our economic peers will be Bulgaria, Russia and Kazakhstan.

I liked his colourful analogy suggesting that we have been kidding ourselves: “There never was a rock-star economy, except in the sense of a once-successful arthritic band loading themselves up on cocaine and methamphetamine to get through the nostalgia tour.”

His bottom line was that our level of productivity sucks. Per-capita GDP growth has stagnated at less than 0.5 per cent since 2008.

Hooton’s focus was on the economy as a whole but his sobering commentary made me think about the long-term effect of gross domestic product growth on media sustainability.

His timing was a little unfortunate. It took the shine off some positive news from two of our media companies in the same week. Continue reading “NZ news media need higher productivity – from the rest of us”

A little spin goes too far in a pandemic

Pandemics require two things: The efficient administering of effective vaccines, and truth.

I need reassurance that the country is receiving both.

The first is the only way we achieve herd immunity without the need for large funeral pyres. The second is vital to maintain public confidence and faith that the Government will get the job done.

Weeks before New Zealand Herald columnist Matthew Hooton wrote his column last Thursday suggesting the supply of vaccine was running out, I had that niggly journalistic sensation in my scalp that there were things we (the public) were not being told. Continue reading “A little spin goes too far in a pandemic”